Our birthday festivities are over (still clean up to do out back though) and I'll share what we did for our homemade eco-friendly pinata other than the felted wool balls that I already mentioned.
Other than these organic lollipops, we did a mostly toy piñata. The NaturalCandyStore.com is a great source for organic & natural candy.
Colored twig pencil bundles were a huge hit. I got these in bulk from an eBay seller a few years back for Halloween and still had these left over.
These mini play clay samples from Mama K were also well received. They are scented in unusual scents like lemongrass, cardamom and lavender with real essential oils. We love them! You could of course get some tiny containers and make your own play dough if you are so inclined. I'm so in love with the texture and scent of these I'm taking a break from making my own.
Little handmade wee wooden vehicles. I only had a handful of these.
Other things we included that I don't have photos of that I found in local craft stores: bouncy balls, mini-watercolor pan sets, erasers, crayons and tiny bubble jars.
The finished handmade pumpkin piñata! My son helped me paint it. I'll post a tutorial soon.

We glued some leaf cut outs to small kraft gift bags for the the kids to collect their loot in.
Party decorations! Most everything we used was handmade or from our yard. He wanted an "autumn theme" this year so it was lovely. Except the part that it was 108 degrees on party day. Didn't feel like autumn, that is for sure.
Did I mention the boy asked for pumpkin pie in lieu of cake this year? It was my tradition when I was a child, I never had cake - always pumpkin pie for my October birthday. Remember the cake fiasco last year? I was relieved when he suggested pie this year, and pumpkin at that. No suggestion from me even. Not that it didn't come with its own problems. We accidentally made a double batch. So instead of three pies we wound up with SIX. Oops! Pie anyone?
This is the kids table. Sadly, I don't have any photos of the finished space with the chairs and the rest of the decorations. Such is the case when you are in a whirlwind of birthday partying.
It was the perfect way to celebrate my eldest autumn boy. Pumpkins, acorns, friends, family and food outdoors.
--------------------------
PS - Welcome to all the new folks that headed over from SouleMama! I'm so happy you are popping over to check out my corner of the web and hope you stick around.